Eric LeVine, founder and CEO of CellarTracker, visits the cellar at his Seattle dwelling.
Before there was Facebook, there was CellarTracker.
Eric LeVine, a former Microsoft worker who fell in love with wine on a bicycling journey in Italy, created the web site for his personal use in 2003 and launched it to the public a 12 months later. In 2005, he left his day job.
CellarTracker’s development popped during the Covid-19 pandemic as wine retailers went digital and shoppers sought out locations to be taught extra about wine. CNBC caught up with LeVine for the inside story on the app’s beginnings — and the way CellarTracker’s founder sees his prospects for the future.
CellarTracker made a reputation for itself as a spot to search for wine varietals and purchase bottles by means of different websites, comparable to Vivino. E-commerce itself was by no means LeVine’s prime precedence. Instead, the wine app helped lovers handle what they’ve readily available, resolve when to open wine bottles and work out what they may need next.
That gave the impression to be exactly what customers wished. CellarTracker counts 11 million annual distinctive guests, and tens of hundreds pay for the service, which affords 9 million critiques of virtually 4 million totally different sorts of wine.
Now, it is increasing, together with different wine-oriented firms as shoppers improve their on-line spending.
CellarTracker acquired on an entire new observe in November 2020 when it took on an unspecified sum of money from angel buyers.
“What I’m trying to do now is a start-up,” LeVine informed CNBC in an interview. The firm’s headcount sprouted from 4 folks to 13 in 2021, with new hires in information science, engineering, design and advertising and marketing. LeVine stated he desires to experiment extra and discover new income sources.
It’s good timing. The wine world has change into more and more digital during the pandemic. Even with lockdowns, U.S. consumption was flat in 2020 in comparison with the year-earlier interval, in response to an estimate from the International Organization of Vine and Wine. But on-line channels represented over 9% of U.S. wineries’ whole gross sales in November, up from 2% in April 2020, stated Rob McMillan, founding father of Silicon Valley Bank’s wine division. He stated he may see it reaching 20% of all gross sales in 5 years.
In March 2020, wineries closed tasting rooms and folks stopped visiting eating places. Those two components stripped out significant income sources that many wineries took with no consideration.
“Almost overnight we went from having the best start to a year we’ve ever had to effectively losing all of our restaurant, hotel and wine shop business overnight,” stated Michael Kennedy, founding father of Component, which makes wine in Napa Valley and the French area of Bordeaux.
Larger wineries had conventional distribution channels that carried their wine to grocery shops in place. Foot visitors declined in smaller areas, though folks continued to purchase in supermarkets by means of supply companies comparable to Instacart.
Some wineries already had their very own wine golf equipment, by means of which they shipped bottles to members. Then there have been wineries that had not diversified to benefit from digital gross sales. Online wine retailer Yahyn, which began in 2019 and struggled to have calls answered by wineries, abruptly began receiving 15 inquiries per week in March and April 2020, managing associate Pierre Rogers stated.
Meanwhile, funding in the wine enterprise began to growth. “You see capital coming into the space in a big way from private equity and venture capital. I’ve seen it in the last year and a half, two years,” stated Irv Goldman, CEO of Acker Merrall & Condit, an organization that holds wine auctions and maintains a New York store. The variety of visits to the firm’s web site doubled from February 2020 to August 2021.
Among different developments, the on-line wine membership Winc debuted on the New York Stock Exchange in November, and Vintage Wine Estates, a bunch of wineries, began buying and selling on the Nasdaq Composite in June after combining with a special-purpose acquisition firm.
“If you didn’t do well in the pandemic, you made some mistakes because it was a good time to be a wine retailer,” stated Gary Westby, the Champagne purchaser at Okay&L Wine Merchants, which has three California shops.
Some buyers have doubts about their probabilities in the wine market. But entrepreneurs are extra optimistic. It’s doable for a wine firm to be valued at $10 billion, stated Heini Zachariassen, founding father of Vivino, a web based wine retailer with an app folks use to search for bottles by photographing labels with cellphone cameras. Vivino, with 55 million customers, announced a $155 million funding spherical in February, at an estimated valuation of $500 million to $1 billion.
CellarTracker is not in the Vivino league simply but. Its web site hasn’t modified a lot in the previous 9 years. Light yellow and burgundy backgrounds set a predictable theme, with textual content forged in longstanding Microsoft fonts comparable to Georgia and Verdana. The firm launched its cell apps in 2014. The homepage reveals a photograph of LeVine’s private cellar.
Profile pages for particular person wines show user-generated “community tasting notes” and scores on the wine world’s 100-point scale, the proportion of bottles that customers have consumed and consuming home windows. People can add or take away wines from cellars, put up public or personal notes, add label photographs, submit food-pairing options and examine related common wines.
Before a redesign in 2012, there have been no notifications, no miniature profiles whereas hovering over wines and no facet panels containing wealthy info next to look outcomes. To appease those that do not respect change, LeVine launched a traditional mode that supplied entry to the outdated interface.
“We have people who are like, ‘Don’t ever take the classic site away, and don’t change a thing,'” he stated. “There’s always a subset of people like that. If you only listen to those folks, maybe they’re going to be the only people using the site someday.”
While the website is acquainted to outdated timers, it isn’t a cutting-edge web property that pulls thousands and thousands of recent customers every month. And it is not doing a lot with its information, which different firms cannot simply replicate.
Others, although, acknowledge CellarTracker’s worth. LeVine stated he has walked away from 9 acquisitions, joint ventures or investments, together with from Robert Parker Wine Advocate, which popularized the 100-point scale, after deciding he did not wish to cede management.
Instead, in 2020, he determined to spice up CellarTracker with outdoors funding underneath his phrases. His lead investor is Brad Goldberg, a former basic supervisor of Microsoft’s search enterprise, who LeVine first met in 1997.
In 2021, the firm employed its first information scientist, Eric Hullander, who started making observations about how lengthy it may well take wines to mature. Larger social networks comparable to Facebook and Microsoft-owned LinkedIn make use of scores of information scientists to assist develop data-powered options and analyze utilization.
LeVine stated the firm is assembling an advisory group of wineries to determine what they want, together with a presence on the website and a way of giving info to shoppers.
Then there are retailers. Scores and critiques from CellarTracker customers are extra plentiful than these from skilled critics who may present useful context for on-line shops.
But the firm desires to proceed with care, to keep away from jeopardizing the website’s repute as a productiveness app for wine nerds.
“No creepy sh**, in a nutshell,” LeVine stated. “You look broadly at technology and social media, and we’re awash in companies doing really creepy stuff with our data. We’re just not going there.”
If something, CellarTracker has been too quiet.
“If I email people twice a year, it’s a lot,” LeVine stated. “We’ll start to do a little more of that and let people turn that up or turn that down.”
The relative lack of nudging interprets into fewer causes to verify CellarTracker for updates.
Jackson Rohrbaugh, a grasp sommelier and president of the Seattle-based on-line wine membership Crunchy Red Fruit, stays on prime of his wine assortment utilizing an Excel spreadsheet, however he visits CellarTracker to learn tasting notes on sure wines.
“There’s times where it’s super helpful,” he stated. “It’s such a cool community that’s come together to provide these really interesting wine notes.” But he reads the critiques with skepticism. Sometimes folks would possibly at first seem like specialists however, in truth, will not be, he stated.
That does not imply the crowd cannot decide wine the means critics do. A 2016 Vox analysis of CellarTracker customers’ wine scores confirmed a constructive correlation with scores revealed by U.Okay. critic Jancis Robinson, International Wine Cellar and Wine Advocate.
Even Rohrbaugh has issues about scores from critics. They would possibly strive 5 wines in a single sitting, he stated, however that is not how most individuals drink wine.
With so many decisions out there to shoppers, although, critics can present worth. Subscribers nonetheless pay to know what critics suppose.
Tim Komada, founder and managing associate at enterprise agency Deep Fork Capital, as soon as adopted Wine Spectator and Wine Advocate, however he let his subscriptions lapse. Instead, he pays yearly for CellarTracker’s service.
“I am more likely to research (and trust) wine ratings via CT and its community ratings system than I am a singular publication that prints a singular critic’s scores/ratings,” he wrote in an electronic mail.
Komada, who moved to Philadelphia earlier than the pandemic after 18 years in the San Francisco Bay Area, maintains over 1,000 bottles on his CellarTracker account, which he is had since 2009.
“If it’s not in there, I just totally lose track of it,” he stated.
Much of the assortment is with him in Philadelphia, however the relaxation is in storage, and CellarTracker reveals the place totally different bottles are situated and the way a lot the whole lot is value.
“I don’t mean this in a bad way, but it kind of reminds me of Craigslist, versus all the other people who have come up against it,” he stated. “It’s been there. It’s the market industry standard. It’s functional enough. And there have been companies that raised millions of dollars for similar things. CellarTracker has survived and thrived.”
It outlasted Vintrust, a start-up Komada co-founded in 2003 that saved wine for collectors and helped them handle stock. Vintrust, which shut down its client storage enterprise in 2009, was as soon as excited by buying CellarTracker, however LeVine balked, saying he wished to deal with natural development, Komada stated.
In 2019, relations and pals gathered at the revered Seattle Italian restaurant Bisato to have a good time the fiftieth birthdays of LeVine and his spouse, Suzi. Late into the night, after most individuals had left and LeVine had ordered a number of bottles of Barolo and Burgundy wines so folks’s glasses would not be empty, he acquired to speaking with Goldberg, his former Microsoft colleague.
LeVine had simply obtained a suggestion to promote management of the enterprise, and he was making an attempt to determine his next step. We ought to sit down, Goldberg informed LeVine, they usually discovered a desk to be alone collectively. Goldberg informed him he had suggested many CEOs earlier than, and that he was completely happy to be of assist.
Two days later LeVine and Goldberg have been speaking for hours over espresso. Goldberg stated he helped LeVine “get clear” on what he wished.
“I was so cautious,” LeVine stated. “I saw so many other things screw up because of too much ambition. If CellarTracker was going to screw up, it was because of a lack of ambition.”
Later, the wine entrepreneur and Goldberg introduced in Russ Morgan, who had labored in administration at Amazon and Microsoft. Morgan would later be a part of as CellarTracker’s working chief. Goldberg gave LeVine quite a lot of choices, together with an funding, and that is the one he selected.
Institutional enterprise cash may need been too excessive for an 18-year-old firm. Having cultural alignment from particular person buyers proved to be extra appropriate, stated Goldberg, who has revealed 185 tasting notes in his 15 years on CellarTracker.
Now, Goldberg stated, there’s room to make current features simpler to make use of for newer members, and to change into important for researching what to buy next. If these initiatives are profitable, then new ones can observe. And over time the firm may tackle extra outdoors cash, Goldberg stated.
“I want CellarTracker to be thriving 10, 20, 40 years from now,” LeVine stated.
WATCH: Significant ‘upwards wine market’ over next 2 to three years, says Bordeaux Index